Dvar Torah · Rav Mordechai Burg
Vayeitzei – The Malachim Who Couldn't Go Home
Nov 22, 2026 · 6 pages
Opening the article…
Read as plain text
N I T Z O T Z O S D I V R E I T O R A H / V A Y E I T Z E I The Malachim Who Couldn't Go Home Rav Mordechai Burg וַיַחֲלֹם וְהִנֵה סֻלָם מֻצָב אַרְצָה וְרֹאשd ו ֹ מַגִיע ַ הַשd ָמָיְמָה וְהִנֵה מַלְאֲכֵי .ֹאֱלֹהִים עֹלִים וְיֹרְדִים ב ו And he dreamed, and behold, a ladder was standing on the earth, its top reaching the heavens, and behold, angels of Hashem were ascending and descending upon it. B E R E I S H I S 2 8 : 1 2 A N E S S AY O N P A R S H A S V AY E I T Z E I N I T Z OT Z O S . C O M Why were the malachim ascending before descending? Malachim come from Shamayim. Shouldn't they first descend and then ascend? Rashi explains that the malachim who had accompanied Yaakov Avinu in Eretz Yisrael were returning to Shamayim, and new malachim were descending to accompany him outside Eretz Yisrael. But the Midrash (Bereishis Rabbah 68:12) offers a fascinating explanation. על ידי שגילו מסטורין של ,מלאכי השרת :שמואל בר נחמן אמר 'לוי בשם ר 'ר .ח שנה"נדחו ממחיצתן קל ,ה"הקב The malachim who revealed the secrets of Hashem were banished from their heavenly place for 138 years. What secrets had they revealed? When Hashem decided to destroy Sedom, He said, הַמְכַס ֶׂה אֲנִי מֵאַבְרָהָם אֲשd ֶׂר אֲנִי עֹשhֶׂה, "Shall I conceal from Avraham what I am doing?" (Bereishis 18:17). Hashem chose to reveal His plans to Avraham Avinu. But the malachim who arrived in Sedom told Lot that the city was going to be destroyed. They had not been given permission to share this information with him. The Midrash offers a second explanation for their punishment. The malachim declared, כ ִי מַשd ְחִתִים אֲנַחְנו אֶׂת הַמ ָקוֹם הַזֶׂה, "For we are destroying this place" (Bereishis 19:13). They spoke as though they were responsible for the destruction, rather than acknowledging that they were merely carrying out the will of Hashem. For this, they were banished from their place in Shamayim. And when did they finally return? .עולים ואחר כך יורדים ,עולים ויורדים ,כאן ?היכן חזרו Here, in Yaakov's dream, when the Torah describes the malachim ascending before descending. R A V M O R D E C H A I B U R G P A R S H A S V A Y E I T Z E I N I T Z OT Z O S .C O M · D I V R E I TO R A H 2 The malachim who had been banished after the destruction of Sedom were finally returning to Shamayim, 138 years later. But why did their punishment end specifically now? What does the return of these malachim have to do with Yaakov Avinu? And perhaps there is another question worth considering. Why does the Midrash specifically mention 138 years? The commentaries explain that this is the precise number of years between the destruction of Sedom and Yaakov's dream. But perhaps there is a remez in the number itself. The gematria of חלק, a part, is 138. I wonder if this gives us some insight into the nature of the malachim's failure. A malach is a shaliach. He has no independent mission. His entire purpose is to fulfill the will of Hashem. But when the malachim revealed information they were not authorized to reveal, they stepped outside the boundaries of their shlichus. And when they said, "We are destroying this place," they took ownership of something that belonged to Hashem. The malachim had begun operating as though they were independent, rather than recognizing that they were part of something greater than themselves. This is what fragmentation looks like. A part begins operating independently of the whole. It loses sight of the larger purpose that it was meant to serve. Perhaps this is why their punishment lasted 138 years, the gematria of חלק. They had lost their proper relationship to the whole, and they could not return until that relationship was restored. Now consider what was happening to Yaakov Avinu. Yaakov was running away from Eisav, who wanted to kill him, and heading toward Lavan, who would spend the next twenty years deceiving him. His situation was genuinely dangerous, and he had good reason to be afraid. The Torah tells us that Yaakov took stones and placed them around his head. Rashi explains that he was protecting himself from wild animals. The Gemara (Chullin 91b) tells us that the stones began arguing with one another. Each stone insisted that Yaakov should rest his head on it, until Hashem made all the stones into one. R A V M O R D E C H A I B U R G P A R S H A S V A Y E I T Z E I N I T Z OT Z O S .C O M · D I V R E I TO R A H 3 What are Chazal trying to tell us with this strange story? When a person is afraid, different parts of his personality may respond in different ways. One part wants to run away. Another wants to fight. Another wants to control the situation so that nothing unexpected can happen. Each part believes that its way of protecting us is the right way. These protective responses aren't necessarily bad. Often, we genuinely need them. The problem begins when they take over, and we lose the ability to respond from a deeper, more grounded place within ourselves. The stones surrounding Yaakov's head were there to protect him. But even the stones were competing with one another, each wanting to be the one upon which Yaakov rested his head. And then they became one. Perhaps Chazal are describing something about Yaakov's own inner experience. Despite the danger he was facing, Yaakov was able to bring the different parts of himself into alignment. They no longer needed to compete for control. Each part could fulfill its proper role within the larger whole. And what did he see when he fell asleep? A ladder connecting Shamayim and Aretz. Yaakov was not being asked to escape his physical reality in order to connect with Hashem. The ladder was firmly planted in the ground. His human experience, with all of its fears and uncertainties, was not separate from his relationship with Hashem. He could be fully present in this world while remaining connected to Shamayim. This may explain an otherwise puzzling detail in the Midrash. Bereishis Rabbah (68:12) records a disagreement between R' Chiya and R' Yanai co
Keep the spark alive
New shiurim, in your inbox
Rav Burg's new shiurim and divrei Torah, straight to your inbox.

