Get new shiurim by email Powered by Consult With Ari (opens in a new tab)

Shiur · Rav Mordechai Burg

Vayeitzei — Bearing Withness

Nov 20, 202642 minTranscript
Listen nowPicks up where you left off · speed up to 2×
Download
A flock of sheep moving across the hills in evening light
What happens when someone you love is suffering, and there's absolutely nothing you can do to make it better? Rachel Imeinu turns to Yaakov Avinu in desperation and cries, "Give me children, and if not, I am dead!" Yaakov responds with anger. The Ramban asks a remarkable question: Is this how Yaakov should have responded to his wife's suffering? In this shiur, delivered at the Lebowitz home in the Valley in Los Angeles, Rav Burg explores the psychology of helplessness, the difference between healthy emotional boundaries and emotional distancing, and why we sometimes become angry with the very people we most desperately want to help. Chazal draw a fascinating connection between Yaakov's response to Rachel and Yosef's response to his brothers. Both use the exact same words: "Am I in the place of Hashem?" Yet one response creates distance, while the other offers extraordinary comfort. What did Yosef understand about suffering that Yaakov struggled with in that moment? And what can we learn from Avraham Avinu about listening to someone else's pain? Sometimes we become so focused on trying to fix someone's suffering that we forget what they may need most from us. Not a solution. Not advice. Just the reassurance that they don't have to go through it alone. For amazing shiurim from Rav Burg, check out Nitzotzos.com.

Transcript

Automatic transcript; may contain mistakes, especially in Hebrew.

Every day as a small business owner feels like solving a puzzle. One moment you're cruising along and the next there's a shipping snag that has you scrambling. But here's a surprise you will like. With Progressive, small business owners save 10% or more on their commercial auto insurance when they pay in full. So go ahead, surprise yourself, get a quote in as little as 8 minutes. At ProgressiveCommercial.com, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates discounts not available in all states or situations. Running a business means keeping a lot of things in your head. Leads, deals, follow-ups. That thing Bob said he'd send on Tuesday. Ah, Bob. HubSpot's self-updating CRM remembers so you and Bob don't have to. It keeps everything up to date automatically, so you can build demand, move deals forward, and automate the admin that's been living rent free in your brain. Learn more at hubspot.com.

In as little as 8 minutes at progressivecommercial.com, progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates and third party insurers coverage is not available in all states or for all vehicles and covered selections. Your business is growing and so is your to-do list. But updating the CRM will not be on it. Because with HubSpot, updates happen automatically so you can build demand and move deals without all the admin. Learn more at HubSpot.com. One of the most painful things in Safer Barretius that we very often kind of, I think, not skip over but move fast through the sukim of the fact that the imahos were childless. We just kind of move past it because it's deeply uncomfortable to think about. And there's a lot of wisdom in those sukim. It's not obvious that people are able just to have children. And for people that struggle, sometimes for months, sometimes for years, I literally was just talking to somebody today.

Read the full transcript

I've been trying for two and a half years to be able to have a child and it's not yet Zocha. Some people go for decades. A person on my block wasn't Zocha to have children for 20 years. And then miraculously had a child after 20 years, one kid. It's a... it's a pella. It's a pella that you know we have children, that's Hashem healthy children and we take it for granted. I myself became a father again recently. We just had a six-month-old daughter and we have three grandchildren. If you were wondering if I'm Hasidish, yeah, I clearly am. Rachal Emeinu in this week's Parsha Can't Have Children. And she turns to Yecha V'venu and she says Haveli b'onim, give me children, ve'imayin mei sa'anayechi. And if I can't have children, then I'm dead. That's a very real pussic. We fly through a pussic like that.

You can't fly through a pussic like that. To hear a woman, and it's different for men and for women, the challenges of infertility Chassidah The Amayin Meisah Anochi is a tragic, tragic sentence in the Torah. I think there's maybe like a handful of sukkim that are just so tragic that they're difficult to read. Rachalim Meinu Terning to Ya'quvyn Saying V'imayyin Meisah'anaichyev I can't have children, what's the point? Because that's what it means, that's what it means to be a Jewish woman, is to be a Jewish mother. And there's just no escaping that. We could try to say, okay, B'seidar Hakadosh Baruch Hu didn't gift you in this time, but at the end of the day it's, it's not a good thing to do. And there's just no escaping there. We could try to say, okay, the Seder Hakadosh Baruch Hu didn't gift you in this time, but at the end of the day, it's like I'm not a human being.

I'm not a human being. There's no point in my life if I can't have children. And Yaakov Vinu's response is kimmat unintelligible. What does Yaakov Vinu respond? So first it says, Vayeich ha'ath Yaakov Barachah. The Yaakov vinu becomes angry at Rachel for expressing the sentiment, which is like, it's difficult for us to believe. First of all, we sensitize ourselves. This is Yaakov vinu we're speaking about. This is not our husbands. This is Yaakov vinu. Yaakov vinu is HaTzaddik. What does it mean to be HaTzaddik? To be HaTzaddik means to be in self. That's what it means to be HaTzaddik. It means to live in total alignment with Hashem. To live in total alignment with Hashem means to be sensitive to other people. Kavachom are the people that we love. So to hear that his wife is turning to him with such pain and saying, Please give me children and if not, I'm dead, and the Ya'aq of Vinu could respond by getting angry, is kimma impossible to understand.

And he says the words to her, Vayei merha takha selo kemanaichi. Am I in place of God? And that's like a... of all the responses that we would expect from Yaakov Avinu, that's the least likely response. Am I in place of God? Asher, Amam nami mech prebeiten? Am I the one that's withholding the fruit of your womb? It's like an impossible thing to understand that Yaakov Avinu's response is to be angry, to be frustrated, and you think, I'm doing this to you. That's like what I would respond. It's like not what Yaakov Avinu would respond. And that's what I would respond if I was like really at my wit's end. In my life I've had the opportunity to speak to talmidim who are struggling with fertility. And I see the compassion that they have. How could the talmidim have more compassion than Yachavinu? What exactly is going on over there?

And also just stop to ask the question, what exactly was Rachalimenu expressing? So we know that what she wasn't saying is Yaakov Vino, you're responsible for me. Like you're responsible to give me children. Like, Rachalimino, she was asking a real thing. Haval-Ibanim is a real thing. If she's saying give me children, what does that mean? What precisely is she asking for there? Because she's also a tzedekes. So she knows that she's not in control, that Yaakov Vino is not in control. So Rashi explains that Rachael Emeinu is asking just like Yitzchuk Daven for ifka, Daven for me. So that's not an unreasonable request. It makes sense, Daven for me. But that also is going to be difficult to understand as we'll soon see. Does that mean that Yaakovinu wasn't Davening? Is Yaakovinu wasn't Davening for her? It's also difficult to understand. In Yaakovinu's response, Rashi tells us, also very difficult to understand, Yaakov Vino's response is, the situation between Yitzchuk and Rivka and me and you is different. Yitzchuk and Rivka had no children. I already have kids with Leah. Right, that response is exactly what I think all of us, if we would actually stop and read the b'sukim and read the rashi's, the audible gasp of, oh my god, Yaakov Vino not only does he get

What are we talking about over here? Not only would I not want my children to learn this lesson, it's impossible for this to be the B'shat. And yet it is what the Reishaimim say. It is what Rashi says and it is what the Ramban says. But the Ramban himself had this kasha. The Ramban asks, He says, Vechayat Sadiqim enm espalim bada chayram. Is it possible the Yaakov V'vino wasn't davening for Rachol? What does it mean to be a tzadik if not to daven for somebody else? That's what it means to be a tzadik. It means to be sensitive to other people. Yom Tov Vayeitzei Bearing Withness So obviously Yaakov was davening for her. So if Yaakov was davening for her, then it becomes even more difficult to understand. So Yaakov was sensitive and he was davening for her and she comes and says, daven for me? Of course he's davening for you. The whole story makes no sense. You understand?

I'm talking around it, but the story has so many holes that once you pay attention even a little bit, it starts to fall apart. Not only that, but there are Mban quotes of Medrash and Beresh's, Beresh's Raba. And Mban says as follows, it's an amazing, amazing Medrash. He says, Amr le'ach Kadosh Baruch Hu. He says, kach einen. Is this how you respond, Esam eikai? This is how you respond to people that can't have children? Because the Rebbanish home is critical of Yaakov vinu. This is how you respond to people that low Alaynu can't have children. He says, Chayecha, by your life Shabbanech Hasidunlamot L'chneibna Because of this, your children, meaning the children of Leah, are going to have to stand in front of the children of Rachim. What is this talking about? So the Mepharshim explained, what did Yaakov Vino say to Rachim? What were the words?

HaTakha Salukim Anochi Am I in place of God, right? And later, all the way, all the way, all the way at the end of the story, when Yois Tirov, don't be afraid of me. Kya takha sallu kemah nayche? Am I in place of God? So it's an interesting phrase. We see this phrase twice. Atakha sallu kemah nayche. You see it twice. When Ya'aqa Vino is being insensitive to Rachol by saying, am I in place of God that I'm the one that's holding you Shabbat Tov Tov shabbat Tov vayuz p Tachazol haKimanochi Am I in place of God? What's Yaysef HaTzadik saying to his brothers? Saying, guys, relax. I'm not in place of Hashem. So it's the exact opposite. What's one got to do with the other? Yaysef HaTzadik is being exceptionally kind. Yaakov Vinu is being, again, I don't mean to speak this way. I'm not HaSashon being critical of Yaakov.

I'm only just trying to repeat what the measure says. But clearly he's being taken to task for the fact that he spoke so inappropriately to Rachel. Furthermore, Rachalimenu also spoke improperly. It's not obvious that Rachalimenu did the right thing by going to him and saying to Daven. Listen to this ramban, an amazing ramban. He says, Dibr Shalok Ahogim B'keh enaso. Actually, he says, Rachalimenu also made a mistake. What was the mistake of Rachalimenu? She was jealous of Laiah. She was jealous of Lai'as. Even though she was a tzedekes, she was still human. And I want to just be careful here, because I don't mean like human like us. We can't understand the godless of Rachali Menu. Even though she gave up her spot to Lai'a to get married, she was still a human being. She still experienced the pain of watching one child after another after another. It was exceptionally painful. And Rambam says she was jealous.

She was, she was jealous. Jealousy Nach hashosh ha'alim like the Iser Doh Raisa of jealous. Jealous like a human being is jealous like look what's happening. The Chashva and what did she think? What did she think? She's watching the parade of children be born. Kiba'ahavaso osa because she said, Yaqovinu, I know you love me. I know you love me. So what did she think? Yis'anah Yaakov v'yilbasaq ve'efir b'yispal a'chi'ul habanim. She said because Yaakov Vino loves me so much, I know that he's going to start fasting and he's going to wear sackcloth and ashes and he's not going to stop davening until we have children. So she wasn't just coming, stam te Yaakov Vino, to say daven for me. What was she saying? She's saying even more than that. And the Ramban says it was inappropriate. YHACOVINU If you really love me, don't eat. Where's Echloth? Where ashes? Don't stop davening until I have children. In other words, she's saying something inappropriate. She's saying, you gotta force Hashem's hand. You gotta force Hashem's hand. But where did it come from?

It came from this jealousy. And that was inappropriate. And why was she so broken? So the Rambam says, and it's based on the Medrash, the Rambam says an unbelievable thing. He says, What is the nature of an akhara? What's the nature of a woman who's infertile? Shehain asuros bitoch batayen va'aluvos. A woman who struggles with fertility, he says they're imprisoned in their own homes and they're depressed. That's the way the Ramban describes it. The Ramban had unbelievable psychological insight. The Ramban understood that a woman who's an akhara lo'alayno, a woman who can't have children, she's homebound. Why is she homebound? She's She's a homebound because she can't go outside. Why can't she go outside? Because then she has to see little children running around. That's the most painful thing. This woman on my block who couldn't have children for 20 years, she's a Gannene. She's a Gannene. You imagine what that's like? She had, I sent my own children to her Gannene because she's an amazing Gannene.

Because, you know, it's like if you're a Gannene and then you go home and then you have to deal with your own kids. Like I'm the son of a teacher. My mother was a teacher. She used all her patience on her kids during the day. And by the time I came home, some of us know the trauma deeper than others. It's a little too true, right? A hundred percent. It happens to me that Baruch HaShaam, I have an amazing mother. But by the time I got home, my mother was like, there was nothing left in the day. She was an amazing Gannane, because she took care of those kids like they were her own. Also, she was able to go for a very long amount of time. She didn't have to leave to take care of her own children But you never saw her in the park on Shabbos. That was too painful Because in Ramabbe Chamesh, we don't have it's not fancy like Los Angeles or New York Where does everyone hang out on the park?

Park benches and all the little kids are running back and forth to their mothers and It's too painful to sit on the bench and watch the children run to their mothers that she couldn't do When she did have children after 20 years Hundreds of people were outside of her home, hundreds were outside of her home when she brought the baby home from the hospital. Because it wasn't just a celebration for her family. We'd been dominating for her family for 20 years. So when she came home it was like music was playing and balloons were everywhere. It was incredible. Now she goes to the park. You see her walking around with her kid and it's like I feel badly because I imagine it's a little obnoxious for her. But every time she's walking in the street with her kid everybody kind of goes... And it's like I'm sure it's painful that she hasn't had any children since it's not so obvious Couple years already kids little now, you know, but like it's but it's like it's like a miraculous child You see this kid this kid is gonna go through the whole system. It's a miraculous child So she was broken She was broken. So of course she was she was she couldn't leave her house She's watching her sister who's in her place have one child after another after another Joseph 3 Many great friends of the Jewish family.

If our husband is Yahurah Vino and he's at Sadeq and we know it's at the special request line Thakal Dush Baruch Hu. Of course, she went to him and she said if you love me, don't stop asking. Don't stop asking. And by the way, she lived there. Right? She's buried on the side of the road because she's the one who won't stop asking Ne'er Bema Nishon to bring my children home. She's not asking for something that she herself doesn't live up to. Yaakov Vevinu is angry, he was davening. She's upset, she's jealous. Yaakov Vevinu says this line of Ataxa Lokemanochi, so one day Yosef is going to say it to the children of Lea. The whole thing is very, very misubach. And one last thing just to point out before we start getting into an answer is the medrus comes in and says, Avram Avinu Vayiach ha'ath Yaakov Baruchal Ya'aqovinu got upset at Ruchal so he's not as good as Avrom Avinu.

Okay, so we're just like pouring gasoline on the fire of how terrible Yaakov Avinu is that Avrom did it better and by the way Avrom did it better but before he didn't do it so well. It's not like he wasn't watching it happen unfolding between the hugger and Sareh Emeinu. He also saw what was happening so it's not so obvious what's going on over here. So I want to share with I think this is very important. Sometimes the people that we love are in such unimaginable states of pain that their pain becomes unbearable to us. People we love are going through something, if it's our spouses, if it's our siblings, if it's our children, and they're really going through it and they're really going through the gehenim of whatever it is that's Coming up in their life, the pain becomes unbearable for us. We can't watch them in their state of pain.

So, let's imagine this case. A woman who, lola lainu, can't have children for many, many years. And she comes to her husband and she says, I can't live like this anymore. I can't live like this. So what's the wife really saying? She's saying, I'm exhausted. I've got nothing left. I know that for the married women this is going to resonate. I'm done. Trigger words for your husband, right? She's saying I'm sad. I have nowhere to turn. Those are understandable human things that they're experiencing. I can't carry this alone anymore. I need your help. I need you to be with me. That makes sense. As a small business owner, sometimes it feels like no matter how much planning you do, there's always surprises, like an urgent expensive repair. But here's a surprise you will like. With progressive, small business owners save 10% or more on their commercial auto insurance when they pay in full.

So enjoy a surprise for once. Get a quote in as little as 8 minutes at progressivecommercial.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates discounts not available in all states or situations. Running a business means keeping a lot of things in your head. Leads, deals, follow-ups. That thing Bob said he'd send on Tuesday. Ah, Bob. HubSpot self-updating CRM remembers so you And Bob don't have to. It keeps everything up to date automatically so you can build demand, move deals forward, and automate the admin that's been living rent-free in your brain. Learn more at HubSpot.com. The wife is trying to share with the husband her pain, but what the husband hears is inadequacy. That's the hardest thing. It takes a very long time to realize, and I think many couples I know I did for sure, certainly in the early years of my marriage. The greatest gift that a husband can give to his wife is creating a safe enough space for her to be able to fall apart.

Men don't know this. You should know. And it's important. If you want this in your marriage, tell your husbands. Men don't know this. Men are very strong. Well, some men are very strong. They were raising young men not to be so strong, which is not a good thing. But in general, men are very strong. They want to be a warrior. And to be a warrior, men tend to think that means to protect my wife from the outside world. But what they don't realize is that it also means to be able to protect a wife from herself. And what that looks like is to be able to say, I'm strong enough for you to be whatever you need to be in this space. It feels, I'll share with you just as being on the other side, if you're not emotionally differentiated it feels like you're the worst husband in the world.

Because if your wife is falling apart and the words that she's saying are directed to you so if you're not smart so what do you do? You just listen to the words. But we have to train ourselves not to listen to the words that come out of people's mouths but to listen to the words behind the words. If your children are coming to you and saying, I hate you, do you realize that means they're coming to you and saying it to you? That means they're in a relationship with you. It means you're actually safe enough for a child to come to you and say, I hate you. So those are impossibly hard words, especially if we've been giving lei veneffesh to those children like I brought you into this world. You have no idea what it means to be a mother. I've raised you. I've put a roof over your head.

I fed you. Not distant, not distant at all, just emotional differentiation, just healthy one step back and you listened to the words that are behind the words, the unspoken words. The unspoken words are, I love you so much, I'm in so much pain and I have no idea what to do with that. That's what our children are expressing. It's the same thing with our spouses. To be not removed at all, just one step back, one step back, to be strong enough to allow Now another person to experience the full range of their being. I've learned this about your half of the species. This is what women want. Women want to be able to experience the full range of their being through the entire spectrum of all of their emotions. By the way, that's not how men live. Men don't even want that. But it's an interesting thing that when a man sees a woman and she's falling apart, She thinks strength in that moment means that she can't feel that way.

What does a man want? That's a whole different thing. Mostly nothing by the way. Mostly just like a sandwich is fine. A sandwich, some space. Just like a... You do private sessions, right? Yeah. But I'll tell you the truth. I just thought you would balance out the conversation. No, I'll tell you why. Women do the same thing but to men on the other side. You have to tell me what you're feeling. He's like, no I don't. And it's not saying, right, right, exactly. And stop trying to pull from me your experience because your experience belongs to you. And I'm allowed to cope with this in whatever way works for me too. And that's okay. It's okay for men to go into their cave. That's a normal masculine thing to do, to pull back and to be able to center themselves in that way. Men don't want to talk about it as much.

The Gemara says that nine measures of speech were given to women out of the ten that I've seen it like I know an emotion. It means that your emotional reality belongs to you and I'm okay and enough for myself that I don't need to pick up your emotional reality and adopt it as my own. I can be empathetic deeply but it's your experience. I'm with you as we'll soon see journeying with you on that experience but it's your experience and you're entitled to that. The moment it becomes my experience now I'm going to interpret it through the lens of my own ego which is my inadequacy. I'm making boundaries. Yeah, but it's not distant. That's the key because most people when they hear emotional differentiation, especially in today's day and age, we weaponize the words boundaries. I'm making boundaries. No, you're just being a jerk.

Boundaries is actually a beautiful thing. Boundaries means I'm giving you absolute clarity on what it looks like to be in a relationship with me so that you can participate. So boundaries is actually pulling somebody and not pushing away. Now, I'm making a boundary. If you're making a boundary to push somebody out, you're not making a boundary, you're just pushing them out. And that's why people don't realize, like, I don't know, my therapist told me that I should be making a boundary. So why isn't it working? Why is my husband more distant? Well, just keep pushing them away and let's see what happens. A boundary is always made lovingly. Remember clarity is kindness, right? So you can say clearly, because I love you, I want to share with you what it looks like to be in a relationship with me. This hurts. This is outside of that boundary. Don't do that. I'm firmly planted in my own soil and you're firmly planted in your soil and you're okay and I'm okay.

You're okay to fall apart. It's okay to fall apart. I'm not afraid that you're going to fall apart. And actually the gift that we give each other when we say to somebody it's okay for you to fall apart is we're actually letting them know that they are enough for themselves, that they're strong enough to be able to fall apart. It takes a lot of strength to fall apart because the fear that we have if I fall apart is that we're not going to fall apart. It takes a lot of strength to fall apart because the fear that we have if I fall apart is what if I lose myself? What if I what if I fall so far apart that I can't get back up? And it's almost never the case because if you genuinely allow yourself to fall apart falling apart doesn't mean that you're falling into oblivion It means that you're actually experiencing your the reality that's inside of yourself So it's true. Rachel Emenu is held to a very high standard There was a jealousy of her sister Sadeikas She was a Tzedekas. Leah never even knew that she was standing in place of Rachal. She never knew.

Rachal Emeinu was such a Tzedekas that she hid from Leah the fact that she gave her the Semenim. But Rachal Emeinu was a human being and she was jealous. And she was, in a certain sense, yes, trying to control the situation. By asking YHK of the Lino, by saying, if you loved me, you would be wearing sackcloth and you would be fasting and you would have ashes on your head Our responsibility in moments of crisis is to let go and to let God. We are not in control of people, places, or things. We're never in control of the reality. We're certainly not in control of the reality of whether or not we can have children. Even by today's day standards we have IVF and you have all the treatments and the hormones. Still, it doesn't work for everybody. There's an organization called Atime. It's a From what I understand, over 8,000 children have been born because of a time.

That's just a staggering number of human beings. We talk about what's a real chassid organization. I think if 8,000 more people, if every child is a blessing and if every person is an entire world, 8,000 plus worlds is just an enormously, exceptionally impressive thing to do with your life. But even they would tell you, maybe it works, maybe it doesn't. Maybe it works, maybe it doesn't. It's never a simple thing. So yes, there was an element of control, there was an element of desperation. And yes, she spoke inappropriately. And Chazal were critical of her for that because tabe'at sade'ka means to completely abandon anything except for our hope in Hashem. That's what's happening in the world today. We're still reaching for straws. We're still reaching this government official is going to help us. And this, it's not true. We now know, right? We have in America for sure, right?

It was like, but at least the Republican Party was with us. And then Trump went on 60 Minutes and said, well, we lost the election because of Israel. It's like, okay, now what? Right? Like, we rely only on Hakadosh Baruch Hu. But yes, it may have been inappropriate. But the question is, what did Yaakov V'Vinu hear? So what did Yaakov V'Vinu hear? Yaakov Vino heard criticism, like come on if you really loved me you would make this happen. So his response to that, for us on our level, his response was what do you want me to do? Was she really criticized? Yeah, no of course not. Of course not. That's the point. The point is that she was having a human moment and it wasn't a criticism but the way that we hear it, I'm telling you as this half of the species, we hear it as if you loved me you would make this happen.

She doesn't mean if you loved me you would make this happen. What she means is, I need you to share this experience with me. I need you to be here with me as I'm going through this. How could Yaakov Vino have said the words, though, I already have children? That's already like, that was that audible guess. How could Yaakov Vino say that? So I want to share with you, I think a pshat that I think is meaningful. I don't know if Yaakov Vino said the words, I already have children. I don't know if Yaakov Vino, It's hard for us to understand that, that Yaakovinu could say that. But maybe he said something like that. And what I think that would look like is this. There are certain times where the words that we say imply emotional distance. Like a certain sense of like, I see that you're going through this, but like, I'm not.

Like I'm not in the same state of desperation that you are. I don't think, not impossible, but it would be very difficult for me to believe that Ya'aq of being like, listen, I've got kids. There are mamari chazal that indicate that like mamish said it like that as some form of tokhukah. For us, for human beings, trying to learn a lesson, I'm not saying it's not true, I just can't get there. Does that make sense? Ma'chas Risham saying that those mafarsham that said it, they weren't 100% right, they were. But for us on our level to understand that a little bit differently, I think we could say like this. If a husband comes to me and he says, my wife is struggling with anxiety, there's two ways that he could say that. He could say, my wife is struggling with anxiety and it's just like, she's really going through it and it's really hard.

And that would imply some sort of closeness. And then there's the guy who's like, yeah, my wife is struggling with anxiety. I was like, where are you in this picture? My wife is struggling with anxiety. I'm not. She is. There's a distance that's there. There's something a little bit like I want to say to that husband, like, if your wife is struggling with anxiety, then you're also on that journey with her. You may not have anxiety, but where are you in this process of somebody you love is going through something? So I don't know if Yaakov Vino said the words, I've already got kids, But certainly whatever he said, the way that Rachel Yimenu heard it was, this is your problem. Like I'm okay. This is your problem. And that distance, that distance was inappropriate. That distance is what Chazal were critical of. Like if Rachel Yimenu is going through something and you love her, then you're also going through.

It's true. She's the one that's going through in a different way than you because she has no children and you have some children. But you're on that journey with her. And if we think about it, this is really what Avram Avinu did. Avram Avinu, like, okay, Saru, I mean, you're hurt. I'm with you. I'm listening to you. I can hear you. And that's what the Pausod literally says, that he heard her voice. He was able to hear her. He was able to hear not just the external words, but he was able to actually understand what Saru was trying to communicate so that he could genuinely connect with each other. And in this area, The Medrash is highlighting that's what Yaakovinu was missing. He didn't listen. He didn't listen. It doesn't mean like he was like a petulant husband who was on his phone and not paying attention. No. He missed it. He thought she was saying something, but he wasn't. She wasn't saying like you said. She wasn't saying Yaakovinu you're not enough for me. You're not being a good enough husband. She was saying I'm really going through this. Where are you? Are you with me?

Like on the flip side, maybe the way he was saying it was, I can't really understand you completely because I'm not in the same place. I do have some children already so I can't possibly know exactly how you are. I want you to know, I thought of that idea also, and I think it's a very beautiful explanation that he was saying, like, listen, it's hard for me to be empathetic here because I don't share the same experience. And I think it's actually a really gorgeous shot. I just don't know if it's the shot that the Ramban is saying and that Rashi is saying because they are critical. In other words, I think if he was saying something like, listen, I'm with you 100%, it's just hard for me to be empathetic because we're not in the same situation. I would have accepted that. Except it's so obvious that they're like critical of him. Yom Tov Vayeitzei

Ya'aq of Vinu has passed away and now Leah's children are in jeopardy. Why are they in jeopardy? Because now Ya'aq of Vinu holds all the power. And the truth is, and I heard this from my Rebbe many many years ago, we see that the relationship between the Shvatim, it never truly got repaired. Because even though when he said those words of Ani Ya'aq of Vinu and he drew them close and they cried, Tati was alive because then that would have been too painful to Tati but he's been waiting this entire time. Now think about that. He's been waiting this entire time as a terrible way to live with a sibling. I think a lot of us feel that way with our siblings, right? And I don't just mean like our biological siblings but definitely with our biological siblings, right? Like how long are you going to hold on to this for?

You ever have a fight like that where like 20 years later you're going to be like, Have a fight like that where like 20 years later it just comes back up and you're like, you serious? We were 16 when that happened. We're in our 40s now. Let it go man. I know, but it was real pain for them. So they're holding onto. So Teshwakam on some level put a Yoan-Safah Tzadok was still holding onto it. So they concocted this whole story. They said you should know that before Yuan-Safah Tzadok died, he said to make sure, and Yoan-Safah Tzadok looked at them and he said, Guys, the same exact words that Yachar Vino used to not make space for Rachal Emenu, the children of Rachal rectified that by saying, didn't we already learn this lesson of what happens when we're in pain and we don't make space for each other?

He said, guys, I'm going to take care of you. You're going to be fine. And whatever you need, I'm here for you. And that's finally when there was a nachama. When Yosef Hatzadeh brings it full circle and he's like, you guys are, you guys are, you're going through something and I'm with you as you're going through it. And look, you're going to have whatever you need. I'm here. I'm a provider for you. That's the nature of what Yosef Hatzadeh was. He was a provider. So the Magish, there's actually a beautiful symmetry to it. What YHK did it do to Rachalimeinu, the children of Rachalimeinu embodied, to make space for somebody who's going through something. As a small business owner, sometimes it feels like no matter how much planning you do, there's always surprises, like an urgent expensive repair. But here's a surprise you will like.

With Progressive, small business owners save 10% or more on their commercial auto insurance when they pay in full. So enjoy a surprise for once. Get a quote in as little as 8 minutes at progressivecommercial.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates discounts not available in all states or situations. Running a business means keeping a lot of things in your head. Leads, deals, follow-ups. That thing Bob said he'd send on Tuesday. Ah, Bob. HubSpot self-updating CRM remembers so you, and Bob, don't have to. It keeps everything up-to-date automatically so you can build demand, move deals forward, and automate the admin that's been living rent-free in your Learn more at Hubspot.com And you immediately step back. That's one way of responding. Then there's another way, which is I can't bear the fact that I can't fix this. I want so desperately to be able to make

this happen for you and I can't bear the fact that I can't make this happen. Because I legitimately can't make it happen. That's why people give advice. Advice is a nasty thing, no? We clap Klaap Al Chayit on Yom Kippur I heard this from Rabbi Dr. Levitz, he's a very well known therapist. He said we klaap al chayit on Yom Kippur for Ya'atsnura, which means I gave bad advice. So Dr. Levitz said, not Ya'atsnura, I gave bad advice. I gave advice and that's bad. What are you giving advice for? You don't need to give advice. They don't need you to give advice. My wife has a line. Don't just do something, sit there. It's a beautiful line. You don't need to run to fix this. It's not what people want. Can you be what's called a withness? I don't have a lisp. Not a witness, but a withness.

To bear witness to somebody is a very beautiful thing, but it implies a certain distance. Like, I can testify to what happened. To be a witness means I can testify to what happened because I'm on the journey with you. That's the gift that we give people. When somebody's going through something, to be able to say, it's okay, I'm on this journey with you. I'll finish with this muscle. A man falls into a hole and he breaks his leg and he can't get out of the hole. A hole is very, very deep. Doctor walks by and he goes, hey, Doc, I fell in the hole. I can't get out. Dr. Writes a Prescription, Tosses the prescription paper down into the hole, and he goes, good luck with that. The guy's in the hole looking at the prescription going, doesn't help me. Then a rabbi walks by. He says, hey rabbi, I fell in a hole. I broke my leg, I can't get out.

And the rabbi pulls out his tehillim, shir lama layz, mi mama kim karazeeh aash ha'imino. It's very nice, I'm still in the hole. And then his best friend walks by and he goes, hey, I fell in the hole. And his best friend jumps into the hole. And he looks at me and goes, you idiot. Now we're both stuck here. His best friend goes, yeah, but now you're not alone. It's okay to be in a hole. It's a tragedy to be in the hole alone. Everyone we know is in some sort of ditch. The people we know are going through something where they have an inner voice that says, The'emayin meisah nochi. Every one of us has somebody in our lives who is going through that. The tragedy is not that they are going through it, the tragedy is that they are going through it alone.

And you might think that you are being a witness with them. But ask yourself, are you really? Are you allowing them to have the full range of their experience? Are you really making space for them? Or do you have that need to go like, come on man, snap out of it. What's the rush? Why do you need them to snap out of it? Because it's not okay. Why is it not okay? Why is it not okay? Because it's like they're so depressed and they just can't seem to get out of it. Right. They're struggling. Telling them to snap out of it and the history. I'm not that old. I'm 46 now. So I'm not that old. But in 46 years on this earth, I have never seen anyone snap out of it because someone told them to. I don't know if you've ever done that. I don't know if you've ever been able to smack somebody back into health.

If you have, you should know you're sitting on a multi-trillion dollar talents. From where I'm sitting, it just seems that we can't control people, places, or things, but what we can is bear with us. We can sit with people and we can be with them in that hole. And I think there's something very precious about this in these moments before Mashiach. As the world is yearning for redemption, and people are really going through it, we're living in a generation of people that are exceptionally lonely. I think Congress passed an act that there's a loneliness epidemic. It's a wild thing. We have more connections than ever before and we're more alone than ever before. And it's not just the secular world, it's also in the Jewish world. People are very alone. We should make space for each other. And Be'ez Zasham, if we make space for each other, the Rebbe Nachman will respond in kind and make space for us. And the ultimate space that the Rebbe Nachman makes is the Be'ezam L'ikdash. Have a beautiful Shabbos. Thank you.

Is this shiur filed in the wrong place? Let us know.

Keep the spark alive

New shiurim, in your inbox

Rav Burg's new shiurim and divrei Torah, straight to your inbox.